Is it okay to spray open-cell foam over a layer of closed-cell foam?
1" closed-cell polyurethane was sprayed on the underside of my roof deck for air barrier by first contractor. Fiberglass batts were to be used for insulation layer. New contractor wants to spray open-cell foam (Icynene) instead of batts.
Sounds like you are shooting for an unvented, conditioned attic.
- A closed-cell foam will qualify as an air barrier.
- Once an air barrier is established at the roof deck, you can supplement the closed-cell foam with just about any product you like.
Is this new construction or an existing home? If it is an existing home, you may need to install some temporary ventilation of the attic and/or a humidifier until the attic acclimates to the conditioned portion of the home.
For more information:
Read Steve Saunder's excellent Q&A "I'm converting my attic into a non-vented conditioned space. Should I use open cell or closed cell foam to insulate?"