Is it better to use a gas or electric heater to back up a solar hot water heater?

Asked by Marge Stevens
Corvallis, OR

We currently have a 1996 vintage gas water heater and are considering replacing it with solar hot water with a 120 gallon electric tank. We have solar pv for electricity. Our 1.8 kW system currently meets our electrical needs.


Rich Franz-Ünder

Answered by Rich Franz-Ünder

Tucson, AZ

Pima County Development Services

July 23, 2010

Hi Marge,

Gas is generally considered more efficient than electric when heat is what you need.

This is because for every unit of energy that you use in your home, one therm of gas for example, it takes 1/10 of a therm of energy to get the gas to you. For electricity, it takes two times the amount of energy, or 2 kwh to get 1 kwh to your home.

There are gas fired water heaters used with solar water systems, like this. But generally people install electric hot water back up systems because they are lower first cost.

If you can do something else with the hot water like heat your house, then the gas fired back up may make sense. We have an installation of a Phoenix system here in Tucson where the hot water from the water heater heats the house through a hot water coil in the air handler.

Hope this helps.


For more information:

Read Paul Rosen's Q&A "Can you tell me how well solar hot-water heaters work?"

Tagged In: solar water heater

Do you have a question about greening your home? GreenHomeGuide invites you to Ask A Pro. Let our network of experienced green building professionals – architects, designers, contractors, electricians, energy experts, landscapers, tile & stone specialists, and more – help you find the right solution.