Question

How do you figure out if a toilet is low-flow?

Asked by Kate
Rochester, VT

We are currently trying to reduce our water consumption in a 10 to 15 year old office building. One way is to possibly invest in a low-flow toilet system. But the existing system may already be low-flow... How do I figure this out? We are on a well, non-gravity fed.

Answer

Molly McCabe, AKBD, CGP, CAPS

Answered by Molly McCabe, AKBD, CGP, CAPS

Bainbridge Island, WA

A Kitchen That Works LLC

February 9, 2011

Dear Kate,

In 1992, Congress passed the Energy Policy Act of 1992, which mandated that beginning in 1994 all residential and commercial toilets use no more than 1.6 gallons of water per flush.

Therefore we can assume, based on the age of the building information you provided, that the toilets in your office building meet the 1.6 gallon-per-flush mandate.

  • However, I hate to make assumptions, because fact is always crazier than fiction and who knows what the building contractors actually installed.
  • If you see no written indication on the base of the toilet, then lift off the tank lid and look inside for a stamp revealing the model number and hopefully the manufacturer's name.
  • Contact the manufacturer and ask them what the flush volume is on your toilets.

Deciding whether to replace a toilet

However, don’t let the fact that you have 1.6 gallon toilets stop you from investigating additional water savings options with your toilets.

  • To begin, do the toilets adequately clear the bowl after every flush?
  • Many of the early low flow toilet releases skipped a step in R&D and performed poorly, requiring double flushing -- or worse, a readily available plunger for clogs.

If your toilets do not consistently clear the bowl on a single flush, it is worth considering buying new units.

HET (high efficiency toilets)

If replacing a toilet, consider a HET (high efficiency toilet). HETs come in two basic flushing volumes:

  • a dual flush, which typically uses 1.6 gallons per flush for solid waste and .9 gallons per flush for liquid waste, or
  • a single flush, which uses 1.28 gallon per flush.

Assuming you are on septic, you need to consider the distance between the septic tank and the location of a single flush HET. If the distance is significant (75 feet or more) and there is little or no assistance from gravity, the single-flush units may be challenged in delivering solid waste to the septic tank.

The next toilet characteristic to consider is noise.

  • Some HETs are pressure-assisted (also called power-assisted or pump-assisted or vacuum-assisted) while others are gravity-assisted (also called wash-down).
  • Pressure-assisted models are generally louder but leave a cleaner bowl than the wash-down models -- making pressure-assisted a good choice for an office building where maintenance costs come into play.

Maximum Performance (MaP) score

Lastly, to help you select the best toilet for your dollar, read the manufacturer’s specification sheet for the unit's Maximum Performance (MaP) score, which measures flushing performance. The EPA uses a MaP score of 350 as a baseline for HETs.

Also, consider a dual-flush conversion kit

If your toilets perform adequately but you are still interested in additional water savings, consider a dual-flush conversion kit.

I have read up on a variety of conversion kits, but the HydroRight from MJSI, Inc., seems like it has the best performance potential -- plus it is very affordable and apparently easy to install.


For more information:

Read Green Home Guide's articles "Tips for Switching to High-Efficiency Toilets, Showerheads, and Faucets" and "5 Tips for Choosing a Low-Flow Toilet."
 

Tagged In: water saving, low flow toilet, dual flush toilet

Do you have a question about greening your home? GreenHomeGuide invites you to Ask A Pro. Let our network of experienced green building professionals – architects, designers, contractors, electricians, energy experts, landscapers, tile & stone specialists, and more – help you find the right solution.